-W EIV widzimy jednak, że Kenobi szkoli L w formie III, każąc mu odbijać laserowe strzały droida-testera.
Szkoli go w odbijaniu strzałów. Nie koniecznie od razu III formy. Ja bym to potraktował po prostu, jako trening zespolenia z mocą. Zauważ, że Luke ma zasłonięte oczy. Podobnie, jak dzieci z Klanu Niedźwiedzia, szkolone przez Yodę w AotC. Używają nawet takich samych zdalniaków, tak na marginesie.
Jak sam zauważyłeś, z początku najmłodszych uczono właśnie stylu I lub przynajmniej, podstaw "obsługi" miecza. Być może, trening na pokładzie ANH był właśnie jakąś formą jego nauki.
Jeśli nie, mogło być tak, że Obi1 wiedząc, że nie ma dużo czasu na nauki młodego Skywalkera, chcąć przygotować go do pojedynku z Vaderem, nie trzymał się sztywno jakichś "reguł nauczania", tylko ćwiczył z nim najpotrzebniejsze rzeczy, jednocześnie podczas nauki walki mieczem, wykładając podstawy filozofii Mocy - "This time, let go your conscious self and act on instinct. You have to enter a state where you act on what you sense, not what you think beforehand" i "Stretch out with your feelings".
Forma III była "wykładana" przy jakimś stopniu wiedzy o mocy i zdolności posługiwania się nią. Luk, jako beginner, nie miał odpowiedniego przygotowania do rozpoczęcia tej nauki, więc ponownie, sądze, że Obi1 zrezygnował ze sztywnych "ram szkoleniowych".
-I skąd Luke uczył sie dalej?? Od Yody??
No między innymi
W "Przewodniku po broniach i technologii GW" napisano:
(...)Podczas szkolenia na Dagobah, Luke Skywalker często zmagał sięze szperaczami Yody - bywało, że nawet z czterema jednocześnie. [strona 204]
W ESB była nawet planowana scena nauki technik walki mieczem Luke`a od Yody, pojawiła się w Marvelowskiej "komiksacji" ESB:
http://www.starwarz.com/tbone/images/cut_scenes/ep5/jedi_training_01.jpg
Więcej na tej stronie:
http://www.starwarz.com/tbone/cut_scenes/ep5/yoda_jump.htm
Tak dla dalszych dyskusji, cytaty z CUSWE
Form I
known as Shii-Cho, this was the simplest form of lightsaber combat techniques studied by the Jedi
Knights of the Old Republic, and was generally considered the first form used by the original creators of
ligthsabers. Sometimes called the ideal form, Form I used horizontal side-swipes and parries made with
the blade of the lightsaber held upright to push the point of an enemy`s blade away during a side-to-side
attack. If the attack is a downward slash aimed at the head, Form I simply reversed the motion, with a
horizontally-held lightsaber being moved up and down to deflect a blow. All the basic ideals of attack,
parry, target zones, and practice drills were created with the Form I style. (VD2, SWI62, SWI68)
Form II
known as Makashi, this ancient Jedi Knight lightsaber combat technique was developed when pikes and
staves were more common in the galaxy. Form II emphasized fluid motion and anticipation of a weapon
being swung at its target, allowing the Jedi to attack and defend with minimal effort. Although many Jedi
historians considered Form II to be the ultimate refinement in lightsaber-to-lightsaber combat, it was
dropped in favor of Form III combat when blaster weapons became prevalent in the galaxy. (VD2, SWI62,
SWI68)
Form III
known as Soresu, this was a lightsaber dueling technique developed by the Jedi Knights, after blaster
weapons became the normal weapon of choice among criminals and underworld beings. Unlike Form II
combat, which was developed to work against another lightsaber, Form III was most effective in
anticipating and deflecting blaster fire. It stressed quick reflexes and fast positional transition, in order to
overcome the rapidity with which a blaster could be fired. It was essentially a defensive technique,
emphasizing the non-aggressive Jedi philosophy while reducing the exposed areas of their bodies. In the
wake of the death of Qui-Gon Jinn at the hands of Darth Maul, many Jedi turned away from the Form IV
style of open, acrobatic fighting and took up Form III in order to minimize the risk of injury or death at the
hands of an opportunistic opponent. (VD2, SWI62, SWI68)
Form IV
known as Ataru, this was one of the more recent lightsaber combat techniques, developed by the Jedi
Knights during the last decades of the Old Republic. It emphasized acrobatic strength and power in
wielding the blade, attributes which were frowned upon by many traditional Jedi Knights and Masters. It
found a niche among the eager padawan learners of the time, who believed that the Jedi needed to
become more involved in rooting out crime and evil and eradicating it. This Form was practiced by Qui-
Gon Jinn, although his death at the hands of Darth Maul exposed the weakness of Form IV in defending a
Jedi`s body. Yoda, however, practiced Form IV with such speed that, when coupled with his small size,
left an enemy with no undefended parts of his body. (VD2, SWI62, SWI68)
Form V
known as Shien, this was one of the seven primary forms of lightsaber combat developed by the Jedi
Knights of the Old Republic. Form V was developed by a group of Jedi Masters who felt that Form III was
too passive, while Form IV was not powerful enough. It addressed the shortcomings of both forms, in
which a Jedi Master may have proved to be undefeatable but could not overcome the enemy. Among the
many unique aspects of Form V was the development of techniques in which the lightsaber was used to
deflect a blaster bolt directly back at the firer, deliberately to cause harm to the opponent. Many Jedi
Masters debated the philosophy of Form V, claiming that it directed inappropriate focus on hurting
another being. Others claimed that Form V was simply a way to "achieve peace through superior
firepower." (VD2, SWI62, SWI68)
Form VI
known as Niman, this was one of the most advanced of the seven primary forms of lightsaber combat
developed by the Jedi Knights of the Old Republic. At the time of the Battle of Geonosis, Form VI was the
standard in Jedi fighting techniques, emphasizing the use of techniques from Forms I, II, IV, and V in
overall moderation. Many Jedi Masters considered it the "diplomat`s form", since the user used their
knowledge of political strategy and negotiation - along with their own perceptions - to reach a peaceful
decision with minimal bloodshed. Many Jedi skilled in Form VI techniques had already spent at least ten
years studying the other four Forms, an aspect that meny Masters felt was too demanding of the Jedi`s
time in regards to its benefits on the battlefield. (VD2, SWI62, SWI68)
Form VII
known as Juyo, this lightsaber combat technique was one of the most demanding of all the forms
developed by the Jedi Knights. Only through the learning of several other forms can a Jedi begin to
understand Form VII, which involved so much physical combat ability that its training brought a Jedi very
close to the Dark Side of the Force. Jedi Master Mace Windu studied the Form VII technique. To master
Form VII, a Jedi had to employ bold movements and be more kinetic than in any other form. Form VII
employed the use of overwhelming power directed through unconnected, staccato movements that kept
an opponent continually off-guard. (VD2, SWI62, SWI68)
Form Zero
originally defined by Jedi Master Yoda to describe the lightsaber technique of Felanil Baaks, Form Zero
became the basis for the instruction of lightsaber combat. In its simplest form, Form Zero is the art of
wielding a lightsaber which had not been ignited. While it seemed silly to many padawan learners, the
underlying message could not be ignored. In order for a Jedi to protect and serve the galaxy, they must
know when to ignite their lightsaber for combat, and when to leave the weapon at his side. The
understanding of another being`s situation was key to the knowledge of right and wrong, and any student
who could understand the necessity of Form Zero and use it to mediate a solution - without resorting to
violence - was truly gifted with the Force. (LFCW)
[Źródła:
VD2 - "Atak Klonów - Słownik obrazkowy"
SWI62 - Insider #62
SWI68 - Insider #68
LFCW - Living Force Camapign, strona WotC - (http://www.wizards.com) ]